Lights
can be split into types Low pressure sodium, High pressure sodium, Fluorescent,
High pressure mercury, (All called discharge lighting) Halogen incandescent,
Basic incandescent, and LED. Because High-intensity discharge lamps are not
recommended for periods of less than one hour and are designed to be some
distance from what they are illuminating with the exception of Metal-iodide
which may be used for garden lighting of the discharge lighting in the home only
fluorescent is really used. The fluorescent and be sub divided with compact self
starting units and those where independent running gear is required.
Because of
Part L requirements builders are forced to use versions with independent
running gear so the bulbs (Electricians call them lamps as they say bulb are
plants but others feel bulb referred to bulbous shape and any device replacing
the original basic incandescent device should go by the same name) can't be
replaces with incandescent types.
In spite of government moves to try to persuade people to stop using
incandescent devices the small spot light seems to be still popular and retail
outlets who have said they are going to stop stocking incandescent lamps seem to
still stock the bulbs for these small spot lights.
Small spot lights
With incandescent types these can be split into extra low voltage and low
voltage (Low voltage is 50 to 1000 volts AC) the extra low voltage have
advantages where low voltage lamps could be dangerous i.e. around water and if
and only if a inverter rather than transformer supplies them better able to cope
with voltages variations.
Inverter An inverter changes the 230 volt AC to DC charges a capacitor
then turns the DC to AC at high frequency then transforms it to voltage required
this incorporates a switch mode method of control and can compensate for voltage
variations they are often called "electronic transformer" and often dimmable
with special dimming unit.

Dichroic
have a special multi-layer coating on the reflector of the lamp this
means that visible light is reflected forwards whilst the heat is transmitted
backwards through the rear of the lamp. The GU10
base at top of picture on left
has a slight taper as it reaches edge of holder where GZ10 below has square
shoulder so non-dichroic GU10's will fit either holder but a GZ10 dichroic will
only fit in a GZ10 holder so only fitting able to deal with the heat coming
through the back of the light can be used. With 12 volt spot lights the
difference between both types is not so easy to see and it is easy to use the
wrong bulb.
There is also the angle of the bulbs beam 10°,
24°, 36°,
60° and colours and size GU4 and GU5.3
There are LED and cold cathode (fluorescent) versions that well fit in
the same base but the lamp is often longer and can end up sticking out of the
fitting.
Quartz halogen lamps produce a little more light per watt than a standard
tungsten bulb and have been advertised as energy saving but it is so small
compared of a saving it can be discounted.
With the wrong distribution or angle they can produce shadows and except where a
skilled lighting expert is arranging and selecting the units they are only
really for show and main lighting is still required.
Because of the numbers of lamps on the same circuit there is a real danger of
overload. To the right is shown the inrush chart not really important as to
which bulb this refers to it is more to show the problem. For the commercial
setup there are all sorts of devices to assist with this problem but in the
domestic market it is normally catered for with multi switching even if all the
switches are switched on together there is likely to be enough milliseconds
between each one to prevent tripping. Unless otherwise recommended by the
manufacturer, a
small spotlight or projector shall he installed at the following minimum
distance from combustible materials: (422.3.1 + 422.4.2)
(i) Rating up to 100 W
0.5 m
(ii)
Over 100 and up to 300 W
0.8 m
(iii)
Over 300 and up to 500 W
1.0 m
Luminaires marked
accordance with BS EN 60598-1 are suitable for
mounting on a normally flammable surface.
similar to F but
where a
thermal insulating material may cover
the luminaire. The
means only can be used on non flammable surfaces. Remember any metal item that can be
touched should be less than 80°C Table 42.1 some
lamps need mounting high to comply with this. Other symbols are used by
manufactures for example
Luminaires are suitable for direct mounting on materials that have normal or
reduced flammability, in which you may not exceed 95°C (in normal operation),
130°C (in abnormal operation) and 180°C (in fault case) for less than 15 min..
Maximum temperature on the mounting surface: 130 °C.
Luminaires
are suitable for direct mounting on materials for which the flammability
properties are not known, in which you may not exceed 95°C (in normal operation)
and 115°C (in abnormal operation fault case).
Wiring
methods
After the second world war many methods were used to save copper and the
ceiling rose became adopted as a method of both suspending the lamp and
connecting the cables.
The
method of taking the line feed to switch through the ceiling rose is very handy
where emergency lighting is required. Klik part of the Hager group produce a
ceiling rose used commercially where the lamp can be just plugged in there have
also been many lighting tracks which will allow the same
but
in the domestic market cost as precluded these and the cheap ceiling rose
is used at less than half the price of the plug in unit. The main problem is
where the brown sleeveing on the blue switch wire is missing and neutral and
switch wire gets mixed up. I did at one time save instructions on how to use
lamp itself as a test lamp to find which wire is which but many seemed to make
mistakes while trying to follow the instructions so I have deleted it.
Other sites
may help. With
power off testing (ringing as originally a bell, battery and couple of
wires would be used) seems best method until switch wire is located.
There are of course many methods that can be used to wire a house. Junction
boxes or even using the switch box as a junction box can be used. One problem is
where screw terminals are used there must be access to the junction box. Often
hatches are made in the floor and marked junction box below but once carpets
have been laid it is unlikely anyone will find these without some form of plan.
And not really accessible. Electricians don't have to follow standard wiring and
one may find many different plans. All Line wires should be brown although using
a sleeve is allowed therefore there is no colour code where three phase coloured
wires have been used for house wiring as common with two way switches.
Intermediate switches as shown left can also be used as two way one connection
left unused. I note MK show Yellow now Grey as common to common wire. Red now
Brown as S1 to S1 and Blue now Black as S2 to S2. And refers to method I show as
"3 wire control" this is most likely followed by many electricians but it is not
a standard. Some old (pre 1966) installations have no earth see
this for more information.
Light/movement/heat detectors
Both indoors and outdoors sometimes automated light control is required.
Switching lights on and off on a regular basis will reduce the life of many bulb
types and the
question must be asked if a 500 watt halogen lamp switched on 20 times in a
night for 5 minuets a time which would average 70 watts over 12 hours would it
not be better to run a 70 watt Metal-iodide all night long? And even these would
in most cases be considered as being too bright. A 9 watt energy saving bulb is
enough to see ones way at the side of my house once it is warm but discharge
lamps are quite a bit dimmer when first switched on. This idea has also been
voiced by the
home office.
So outdoors a standard photo switch like shown to
far left or next to this with timer to switch off after set number of hours
seems better options. There are also lamps with sensors built in. The PIR shown
to right does take some careful setting up with masks etc. Some lamps come with
combined light and movement
sensors which are programmed by switching the supply
off and on so many times these of course are messed up by power cuts. Moving
indoors bottom left is the type of PIR used for stairs and landing. Here a
2 Way + Off switch is used allowing either PIR or switched operation. A
diagram to right shows two different ways to wire. If the power is permanently
on to the PIR it will sense any movement and always be switch to correct mode so
flicking switch between permanent on / off / PIR controlled will get imitate
correct response. But using link within PIR may cause some delay in PIR
switching on. However it would need 4 cores to have independent power so in the
main one would use manufactures link inside PIR allowing standard triple and
earth cable to be used. Position of PIR would dictate this as if close to
ceiling rose neutral supply may go direct. The problem for those following is
the switch would look so similar to standard two way wiring mistakes can be
made. Also any electrical item can go faulty and consideration should be main on
how to isolate the PIR top left is so easy it just unplugs and a plastic bag to
stop rain getting in would mean it can be isolated without a switch but in most
cases an isolator is required.
Earths
![]()
Years ago it was common not to connect earths to lighting supplies and where the
switches and ceiling roses etc where plastic it did not really matter. Since
there was no real problem many electricians would miss out testing the lights
especially since it often required dragging around steps. So although one
shouldn't find any unearthed lights it is still quite common. Because 543.6.1
requires the earth to follow the same route as power cables and 543.1.1 requires
earth wires not incorporated within supply cables to be at least 4mm²
there is as much work add an earth as renewing cable so to correct missing earth
a rewire is required. In the mean time only items marked with
can be used.
The sign
means
it is Class II equipment and does not require an earth. Although isolation
transformers could be used it would be better to use an extra low voltage system
if these were going to be introduced. The
Electrical Safety Council do a number of instruction sheets on how items
like this should be dealt with see
Best Practice Guide 1.
Protective devices
Because many ceiling roses are only rated 6 amp although 559.6.1.6 allows up to
16 amp on a lighting circuit. With the requirement for RCD on bathroom lights
and buried cables rules many lighting circuits will also have RCD protection as
well. When a light bulb blows it often causes ionisation and a resultant short
circuit the MCB's have a magnetic part which can react to this short circuit
quicker then the built in fuse that should be incorporated into every light
bulb. Regulation 314.1 tells us how we should split the installation up into
circuits for a number of reasons including safety and as a result upstairs and
downstairs lights are normally feed from separate fuses. Florescent fittings
also often have their own fuse and any lights taken from the power circuit will
normally also have a fused spur unit. Where BS 1362 fuses are used these should
be 5 amp or less it is common to use 3 amp as it is the preferred size for low
current equipment and most electricians carry them. Where high inrush causes a
problem on switch on as with multiple spot lights on one circuit the B6 MCB may
be changed for a C6 or D6 but before this is done the wiring will need testing
to ensure it still gives required protection and is not a DIY job and should be
notified under Part P as not replacing like for like in the consumer unit
requires the issue of a completion certificate and this is fixed price for most
local authorities so a registered electrician will do it for far less than the
DIY cost. The use of grid switches allows fuses and switches in same unit.
With the 17th Edition lights are now being put on earth leakage
protection devices and it seems may houses have
borrowed neutrals on the stairs lighting circuits. With this in mind the
only safe way to work on the house electrics is to switch off at main isolator
the MCB is not always good enough.
Regulations
I have tried to give wiring regulation numbers in the main so where there are
changes these can be verified.
Part J,
Part L,
Part M and
Part P may also control what is permitted. The wiring regulations alone is a
389 page book which then needs further books to explain what the contains mean.
While writing this I knew there was a regulation to say the earth wire had to
follow the same route as power cables but it took quite a time to locate 543.6.1
and so we get the Chinese whisper syndrome where people think there is a
regulation but have never read it and jump to the wrong conclusions. I feel sure
there will be one on minimum light levels for example but I have not seen one.
In the main common sense must be used. The
17th
Edition (BS 7671:2008) requires earth or RCD protection for wires buried in
a wall where SELV
(Separated Extra Low Voltage) this can not really be complied with so no further
protection is used.
Where Part P requires that inspecting there seems some confusion as to whom
should do this. It seems that the designer and or installer may need to complete
the first
set of results and only if the Local Authority Building control (LABC) wants
to confirm the results do they need to complete a inspection report at their
expense to verify your results. Since most DIY'er with not have the £700 worth
of test equipment required it is unlikely they will be able to complete the
first inspection report page 11 of the Part P document tries to explain who
should do the testing but is full of contradictions and in fact seems to change
area to area so only way it to ask your own LABC. Bathrooms require IPXXB
or IP2X for SELV or IPX4
or if water
jets are likely IP5X
for 230 volt
appliances within zone 2 the symbols should be found on any lights used under
2.25m and within the area of bath or shower tray.
Energy saving
There has been a lot of miss information as to how to save energy. A house is
heated either by radiation or convection the former is very hard to control
whether as open coal fire or quartz electric. With convection however a room
thermostat or radiator TRV can control the temperature with ease. To build up
data on how much a bulb heats the house would need accurate air change
information and even then because one feels warmer with radiated heat the air
temperature can be lower but this needs human intervention as very hard to
measure.
Looking at
Carbon emissions reduction target on the internet and filling in a
questionnaire I did talk to a nice man called
Add to this a whole host of other unknowns like what is really inside an energy
saving bulb and can they compensate for voltage variations.
Add to this the energy costs of making the bulbs
and the environmental impact of the mercury within the
fluorescent
bulbs or tubes leaves it very open as to if they really save any energy when
used in doors. Because they as so effected by the cold not all types can be used
out doors either.
The fluorescent comes in to basic types those using
conventional chokes and starters and those with electronic control gear known a
HF for High Frequency. The conventional chokes type is very voltage dependent
and for a 230 volt unit at 215 volt it will likely fail and at 250 volt be using
twice the ratted power. They rely on a capacitor to give power factor correction
and if this fails it can use a third more power without any outward sign of any
problem. The HF unit however has a very wide voltage range without any increase
in power used often will run on DC as well as AC and can have battery back-up
added tubes last much longer and maintain their output better and although they
use same tubes can cost up to a third less to run. The lamp shown to the right
under emergency lights below will be a HF unit I fitted a second hand unit at
the top of my stairs in 1992 and I have never changed the tube to date 16 years
latter and is in daily use.
With the compact fluorescent however there
is little or no information on how they work and short of dismantling or
installing power monitoring equipment one has no idea what type they are.
However the maintenance
benefits and fire and burning risk is proved and there are many places it does
make sense. In a kitchen under cupboards lighting a counter where it is already
hot and also any tungsten bulbs could easy be touched and burn someone the
discharge bulbs or LED lighting make sense.
It may also make sense where the
heating is not thermostatically controlled or where a high number of lamps are
used for decorative effect.
There are web
sites with energy
saving calculators but it will be noted it does not ask where the bulb is
used and all seem to be on web sites of people selling bulbs! And some bulbs are
very expensive I paid over £7 for the cold cathode GU10 bulb above my bed where
a tungsten halogen one are two or more for a £1 but it is cold so I will not
burn myself if I reach up and move it.
Emergency lights
These
come in two main types non maintained, maintained the maintained type can be
used like an ordinary lamp. The non maintained only switch on with a power
failure. One problem is where discharge lighting is used often a timer is
included to hold the emergency light on when power returns to give time for main
lights to strike. But this is hardly required in domestic use and they start at
about £15 some torches are available which when on their charging base act as
non maintained lights. In commercial premises a key switch would be added to
test the lights but again at home switching off lighting MCB is good enough to
test. The one to left is also a smoke alarm and looks far better than the
standard type shown to the right. With the 17th Edition rules on taking account
of danger that may arise from the failure of a single circuit such as a lighting
circuit 314.1(iii) the use of emergency lights will be balanced out cost wise
with cost of RCBO's so are likely to become more popular in the future.
Light dimming
With
OSRAM DULUX EL VARIO energy-saving light can be varied without the need for
dimmers: the integrated 2-stage dimmer function provides bright or subtle
lighting simply by switching on and off. But in most cases we use dimming
switches.
OSRAM DULUX EL DIM is a new infinitely dimmable energy-saving lamp, which
can used with appropriate lamp dimmers for all applications. There are
others but
most seem to
tell about them but not sell and the dimmer needs to be 6 times bigger than the
bulb size, also my web search failed to find prices, normal energy saving bulbs
can not be dimmed. The Extra Low Voltage lamps also have problems with dimming
trailing-edge phase dimmers and leading-edge phase dimmers (the latter normal
for inductive loads) and trailing-edge phase dimmers
Notes
Fluorescent lamp
starters normally come in ranges 4 - 22, 4 - 65, 4 - 80, 70 - 125 watt and
also types electronic and standard for example FS - U in the main they are
interchangeable but where two tubes are used i.e. fly catchers then the wrong
type number may fail there is also an issue with the tubes some have earth
strips down length and are of different thicknesses often they can be inter
changed but sometimes they will fail the same with wattage a 2 ft tube can be 20
or 40 watt and again sometimes one can get away with wrong tubes but if you want
long service it is better to ensure the correct tube and starter is used. Also
remember they can't be disposed of in general rubbish best way is return them to
shop where they can dispose of them correctly.
The
same applies to extra low voltage spot lights using LED and lower wattage
normally does not cause a problem but the inverters often have a min as well as
max wattage and in some cases using LED lamps will fail and of course using
larger lamps will burn out the transformer/inverter some more expensive
inverters have an auto protection device built in but many don't and burn out.
It is common when changing lights to just shove a connection block up the hole
where the wires come out of the ceiling if then one returns to these lamps one
is often unaware of the out of sight wires which may when disturbed break a
connection. Also the practice may be dangerous when other work is done from
above. It is not possible to cover all aspects and however hard one tries to
avoid dangers accidents will still happen. If your not sure ask, if your still
not sure either ask again or call in an electrician and never work alone. Do
isolate before working and remember both line and neutral are live so better to
turn off power with double pole isolator than single pole MCB or RCBO and
remember if you don't turn off at isolator and you have RCD's then touching
neutral can both give a shock and switch off RCD so log off (switch off)
computers etc before working. Also Wellingtons often contain graphite in the
rubber mix to stop static build up so wearing Wellingtons and the like will not
always protect you from shocks the gloves and goggles worn by supply authority
employees to work on live supplies are special and only real safe way is turn
off supply at main switch.
Since originally making this page a
number of questions have been asked. One big problem seems to be where an RCD is
added either because lights are in a bathroom or the cables are buried less than
50mm in a wall. The
Electrical Safety Council do give some guidance as to new regulations and
where RCD's must be added although they do seem to miss out the option of using
Ali-tube cable.
In this
circuit the power and return
are both coming from the same fuse and both meters show the same current with
this the earth leakage trip will hold in and X1 the landing lamp can be switched
off and on with the right hand switch also both the other lights can also be
switched on and off without any problem.
There are other
drawings on the page showing two way wiring and it
can be seen how one would normally use triple and earth cable. But houses wired
in 1980's often only had a single circuit for lighting and when the split
between two floors first started electricians continued to wire in the old way.
Later it was found this caused interference where the line and neutral did not
follow the same route three cores started to be used. Although technically not
to regulations because of borrowed neutrals until lights started to be put on
RCD protection it was not seen as a problem and as a result quite common. When reading any USA explanations they use the word "hot" where we use "line"
be very careful with the word "live" as this refers to both line and neutral but
some people in error refer to the "Line" and being "Live" which can cause
confusion. And I have from time to time slipped up and used the wrong word. In
this example which is wired identical to the other example but the left hand
switch has switched on X1 and both pairs of meters show different current and
here both earth leakage trips will open. This is called borrowed neutrals
although in real terms it is the line that is borrowed. The circle shows
how three cables should have connected the two switches but only two cables have
been used and the dotted purple cable is missing and a link shown with dotted
red has been used instead.
Unless the twin core is replaced for a triple core cable this can't be corrected
and the only option is to combine both circuits together so they are both fed by
the same RCD.
This may contravene regulation 314.1(iii) unless an
emergency lamp was used. It could also cause problems where many lights are
used and an overload could result but this is unlikely if standard lighting is
used.The light switch
Most
light switches look similar to those shown to the left but some switches are
reversed to each other as shown to the right also there seems to be three common
ways to label. (L1, Com) (L1, L2) and (Plain, Colour) the later is used in the
USA and the common terminal has a coloured lacquer on it. The problem however is
with other two methods as when L1(3+7), L2(1+5), L3(2+6) is used then L1 is
normally the Com but where Com is marked as Com then Com = 3+7 and L1 = 1+5 and
L2 = 2+6 so it is easier to use terminal position on many switches. On a two way
switch (In USA called 3 way) the com will be the odd one out being further away
from the other two terminals shown as 3 and 7 on diagrams. Unused ways often
have the hole but no terminal in the hole. The example to the right reverses the
two switches to make them more compact and care is needed to select correct
terminals. So that no junction block is required when wiring two way switches
the switch wires from lamp go to 1/5 and 2/6 terminals but with normal on/off
the switch wires go to 1/5 and 3/7 terminals there are two common ways to wire
two way switches the method taught is schools is not the normal method used by
electricians.
Wikipedia does
show both methods and how they work. The preferred electricians is shown as
method 2. But is schools we are taught method 1. Since we use the ceiling rose
as a junction box and the "from mains" and "to light" both arrive at the same
switch method 2 does have an obvious advantage.